Pope Francis: Lit as Spiritual Formation

Pope Francis, 1936-2025

 Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Tuesday

I can think of no better way to honor the late Pope Francis than to repost the essay I wrote last August reporting on his extraordinary defense of literature. As I noted at the time, I first wondered whether Francis was apologizing for the Catholic Church’s long and dark history of banning books. And while I think there’s some truth to this, the letter goes far beyond any apology.

Francis sees literature as absolutely essential to our spiritual, intellectual, and physical well-being. He even says that literature can sometimes step in when prayer fails us. The letter is one of the most extraordinary defenses I have encountered, up there with those of Sir Philip Sidney and Percy Shelley.

Francis begins by saying that he wrote his letter originally to point out how literature can contribute to “the path of personal maturity” for Catholic priests but adds that “this subject also applies to the formation of all those engaged in pastoral work, indeed of all Christians.” You can read the letter in its entirety here, but I have pulled out some of the highlights. I quote Francis directly because he articulates his points so well:

–In moments of weariness, anger, disappointment or failure, when prayer itself does not help us find inner serenity, a good book can help us weather the storm until we find peace of mind. Time spent reading may well open up new interior spaces that help us to avoid becoming trapped by a few obsessive thoughts that can stand in the way of our personal growth.

–A book demands greater personal engagement on the part of its reader [than audio-visual media]. Readers in some sense rewrite a text, enlarging its scope through their imagination, creating a whole world by bringing into play their skills, their memory, their dreams and their personal history, with all its drama and symbolism. In this way, what emerges is a text quite different from the one the author intended to write. A literary work is thus a living and ever-fruitful text, always capable of speaking in different ways and producing an original synthesis on the part of each of its readers. In our reading, we are enriched by what we receive from the author and this allows us in turn to grow inwardly, so that each new work we read will renew and expand our worldview.

–I would agree with the observation of one theologian that “literature… originates in the most irreducible core of the person, that mysterious level [of their being]… Literature is life, conscious of itself, that reaches its full self-expression through the use of all the conceptual resources of language.”

–Literature…has to do, in one way or another, with our deepest desires in this life, for on a profound level literature engages our concrete existence, with its innate tensions, desires and meaningful experiences.

–In the end, our hearts always seek something greater, and individuals will find their own way in literature. I, for my part, love the tragedians, because we can all embrace their works as our own, as expressions of our own personal drama. In weeping for the fate of their characters, we are essentially weeping for ourselves, for our own emptiness, shortcomings and loneliness. Naturally, I am not asking you to read the same things that I did. Everyone will find books that speak to their own lives and become authentic companions for their journey. There is nothing more counterproductive than reading something out of a sense of duty, making considerable effort simply because others have said it is essential. On the contrary, while always being open to guidance, we should select our reading with an open mind, a willingness to be surprised, a certain flexibility and readiness to learn, trying to discover what we need at every point of our lives.

–How can we reach the core of cultures ancient and new if we are unfamiliar with, disregard or dismiss their symbols, messages, artistic expressions and the stories with which they have captured and evoked their loftiest ideals and aspirations, as well as their deepest sufferings, fears and passions? How can we speak to the hearts of men and women if we ignore, set aside or fail to appreciate the “stories” by which they sought to express and lay bare the drama of their lived experience in novels and poems?

–From a practical point of view, many scientists argue that the habit of reading has numerous positive effects on people’s lives, helping them to acquire a wider vocabulary and thus develop broader intellectual abilities. It also stimulates their imagination and creativity, enabling them to learn to tell their stories in richer and more expressive ways. It also improves their ability to concentrate, reduces levels of cognitive decline, and calms stress and anxiety.

–Even more, reading prepares us to understand and thus deal with various situations that arise in life. In reading, we immerse ourselves in the thoughts, concerns, tragedies, dangers and fears of characters who in the end overcome life’s challenges. Perhaps too, in following a story to the end, we gain insights that will later prove helpful in our own lives.

–When I think of literature, I am reminded of what the great Argentinian writer Jorge Luis Borges used to tell his students, namely that the most important thing is simply to read, to enter into direct contact with literature, to immerse oneself in the living text in front of us, rather than to fixate on ideas and critical comments. Borges explained this idea to his students by saying that at first they may understand very little of what they are reading, but in any case they are hearing “another person’s voice”. This is a definition of literature that I like very much: listening to another person’s voice. We must never forget how dangerous it is to stop listening to the voice of other people when they challenge us! We immediately fall into self-isolation; we enter into a kind of “spiritual deafness”, which has a negative effect on our relationship with ourselves and our relationship with God, no matter how much theology or psychology we may have studied….This approach to literature, which makes us sensitive to the mystery of other persons, teaches us how to touch their hearts.

–T.S. Eliot, the poet whose poetry and essays, reflecting his Christian faith, have an outstanding place in modern literature, perceptively described today’s religious crisis as that of a widespread emotional incapacity. If we are to believe this diagnosis, the problem for faith today is not primarily that of believing more or believing less with regard to particular doctrines. Rather, it is the inability of so many of our contemporaries to be profoundly moved in the face of God, his creation and other human beings. Here we see the importance of working to healing and enrich our responsiveness. On returning from my Apostolic Journey to Japan, I was asked what I thought the West has to learn from the East. My response was, “I think that the West lacks a bit of poetry”. 

–What profit, then, does a priest gain from contact with literature? Why is it necessary to consider and promote the reading of great novels as an important element in priestly paideia?… Let us try to answer these questions by listening to what the German theologian [Karl Rhaner] has to tell us. For Rahner, the words of the poet are full of nostalgia, as it were, they are like “gates into infinity, gates into the incomprehensible. They call upon that which has no name. They stretch out to what cannot be grasped.” Poetry “does not itself give the infinite, it does not bring and contain the infinite.” That is the task of the word of God and, as Rahner goes on to say, “the poetic word calls upon the word of God.” For Christians, the Word is God, and all our human words bear traces of an intrinsic longing for God, a tending towards that Word. It can be said that the truly poetic word participates analogically in the Word of God, as the Letter to the Hebrews clearly states (cf. Heb 4:12-13).

–As far as content is concerned, we should realize that literature is like “a telescope”, to use a well-known image of Marcel Proust. As such, it is pointed at beings and things, and enables us to realize “the immense distance” that separates the totality of human experience from our perception of it. “Literature can also be compared to a photo lab, where pictures of life can be processed in order to bring out their contours and nuances. This is what literature is ‘for’: it helps us to ‘develop’ the picture of life,” to challenge us about its meaning, and, in a word, to experience life as it is.

–In terms of the use of language, reading a literary text places us in the position of “seeing through the eyes of others,” thus gaining a breadth of perspective that broadens our humanity. We develop an imaginative empathy that enables us to identify with how others see, experience and respond to reality. Without such empathy, there can be no solidarity, sharing, compassion, mercy. In reading we discover that our feelings are not simply our own, they are universal, and so even the most destitute person does not feel alone.

–In reading about violence, narrowness or frailty on the part of others, we have an opportunity to reflect on our own experiences of these realities. By opening up to the reader a broader view of the grandeur and misery of human experience, literature teaches us patience in trying to understand others, humility in approaching complex situations, meekness in our judgement of individuals and sensitivity to our human condition. Judgement is certainly needed, but we must never forget its limited scope. Judgement must never issue in a death sentence, eliminating persons or suppressing our humanity for the sake of a soulless absolutizing of the law.

–The wisdom born of literature instils in the reader greater perspective, a sense of limits, the ability to value experience over cognitive and critical thinking, and to embrace a poverty that brings extraordinary riches. By acknowledging the futility and perhaps even the impossibility of reducing the mystery of the world and humanity to a dualistic polarity of true vs false or right vs wrong, the reader accepts the responsibility of passing judgement, not as a means of domination, but rather as an impetus towards greater listening. And at the same time, a readiness to partake in the extraordinary richness of a history which is due to the presence of the Spirit, but is also given as a grace, an unpredictable and incomprehensible event that does not depend on human activity, but redefines our humanity in terms of hope for salvation.

At one point in his letter, Francis  worries about what happens when literature is seen as non-essential. He is talking about the education of seminarians, but his observation extends to everyone. Dismissing literature as a frill, he contends, “can lead to the serious intellectual and spiritual impoverishment of future priests, who will be deprived of that privileged access which literature grants to the very heart of human culture and, more specifically, to the heart of every individual.”

He also talks about his own teaching experiences in Argentina. When he encountered students who wanted to read the contemporary poet Garcia Lorca rather than the canonical El Cid, he decided to discuss Lorca in class while having the students read El Cid at home. In the process, he discovered that discussing the contemporary poet led his students to appreciate the older one.

I can’t say much more in response to Francis’s letter than a loud “Amen!”

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , | Comments closed

The ICEman Cometh

ICE goes after an immigrant family

 Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Monday

“Some say the world will end in fire/ Some say in ice,” goes Robert Frost’s well-known poem. And while the poem, which in the past I’ve applied to climate change, is really about relationships (fiery anger and cold withdrawal can both be lethal), it works as a pun to capture our current situation. ICE, the acronym for Immigration and Customs Enforcement, has become the Trump administration’s Gestapo, disappearing people off the streets and sending them to prisons and, in some instances, a Salvadoran concentration camp.

In this case, ICE is helping end our constitutional republic since the right of individuals to due process is at the core of who we are. Once the government can lock people up secretly and without a hearing, we have become a dictatorship.

ICE started with immigrants but it has since moved on to people with legitimate visas and green cards, and there have been at least two instances of American citizens being incarcerated before relatives showed up with birth certificates. ICE claimed these were mistakes but according to former Soviet grandmaster Gary Kasparov, who knows authoritarian measures when he sees them, “mistakes” are actually tests: dictators want to see how far they can push their power.

The Iceman Cometh is the title of a Eugene O’Neill play that can be applied to our situation. While there are multiple interpretations of the title, including that it alludes to Jesus’s apocalyptic warning about the bridegroom coming and catching the handmaids asleep, at one level it is a reference to the character “Hickey” Hickman. A successful businessman who returns home each year to throw a party, this year Hickey has another plan: to throw cold water on people’s pipe dreams.

These pipe dreams are rationalizations for non-action. The other characters, all alcoholics, invent continuous excuses for why they aren’t doing anything meaningful with their lives. Instead, they choose to hang around Harry Hope’s saloon. Early on, one of the more reflective patrons delivers a pronouncement that at first put me in mind of Trump supporters:

To hell with the truth! As the history of the world proves, the truth has no bearing on anything. It’s irrelevant and immaterial, as the lawyers say. The lie of a pipe dream is what gives life to the whole misbegotten mad lot of us, drunk or sober.

How are Trumpists to deal with the impending threat of climate change, a Trump recession, and a rapidly changing and complex world? Easy. Just let your leader lull you into the pipe dream that, by asserting white supremacy and going it alone, America can be great again.

The play shows the fury these people experience when someone comes in to wake them up (Hillary Clinton, Kamala Harris). By the end of the play, they have convinced themselves that Hickey is insane and that they can return to their pipe dreams and their alcoholic stupor.

But I want to focus on another pipe dream that is more insidious. This is the one the ICEmen are attacking. The pipe dream is that America has a set of safeguards that will protect its democracy. That our inalienable rights are written into the Constitution and therefore operative. That the courts will affirm the principles of due process, of birthright citizenship, of the rights to speak freely and to assemble,  etc. And that the American people are fundamentally decent. ICE has entered our lives like Hickey into the saloon and ripped these illusions from our eyes.

As we see ICE crossing one red line after another, how long before we see its actions resulting in people getting killed? Domestic prisons yesterday, a Salvadoran concentration camp today, what tomorrow? This, after all, was the trajectory in 1930s Germany, and we know where that ended up. To invoke another ice poem, this one about death, Wallace Stevens writes, “The only emperor is the emperor of ice cream.”

Elsewhere in his poem, Stevens writes, “Let be be finale of seem,” pointing to how the grim reaper will cut through all illusions. Corpses wrapped in winding sheets, resembling “big cigars,” have a way of confronting us with reality. “If her horny feet protrude,” the poet points out, “they come to show how cold she is, and dumb.”

We’re not at the killing stage yet and, with enough resistance, may escape it. We just can’t make the assumption that ICE will stop there given everything else it has done. Right now, our only hope is collective action.

With ICE’s escalating raids in mind, I turn to Martin Niemöller’s famous poem. It’s worth noting that the poem is personal and comes from a deep place. Niemöller was a battalion commander of the paramilitary Freikorps that brutally put down the Ruhr uprising in 1920; he voted for Nazis in 1924, 1928, and 1933; and he was making anti-Semitic statements as late as 1935. He was thus like those former Trump supporters who finally see the light.

In his case, seeing the light landed him in concentration camps until the end of the war, and he narrowly escaped death:

First they came for the Communists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Communist
Then they came for the Socialists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Socialist
Then they came for the trade unionists
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a trade unionist
Then they came for the Jews
And I did not speak out
Because I was not a Jew
Then they came for me
And there was no one left
To speak out for me.

They came for him, and Trump’s ICEmen won’t stop at undocumented immigrants and people with visas and green cards. Ask not for whom the doorbell tolls. It tolls for thee.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments closed

Oliver: My Work Is Loving the World

 Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Easter Sunday

Since beginning this blog, I have often shared a Mary Oliver poem on Easter Sunday. I do so again today since, in “Messenger,” she grapples with the Jesus miracle that we celebrate today and that is the most difficult to accept.

While I don’t myself entirely believe that Jesus came back as a living, breathing human being—one who (so Luke reports) made multiple appearances, such as walking through locked doors, suddenly vanishing, participating in a meal, and presenting his body to be touched—I do believe that he articulated a deep and transcendent truth about the nature of being. It is this truth that Oliver is getting at when she makes reference to living forever.

Oliver so loves the world that, when she fully enters into creation, it no longer matters that she is aging. Her “body clothes,” like her boots and her coat, may be wearing thin, but her connection with the moth and the wren and “the sleepy dug-up clam” means that she transcends self to become part of something larger.

Oliver is able to reach beyond the drama of life and death because, like sunflowers and hummingbirds, she is a seeker of sweetness. She offers up thanks that she has a mind, a heart, and a body through which she can experience the world, and she offers up thanks that she can voice her gratitude. “Songs of songs of thankfulness and praise, Jesus, Lord, to thee we raise,” goes the old Victorian hymn, and Oliver’s poem works as such a hymn.

For a creative writer, voicing words of thankfulness and praise is particularly important. In his novel All the Pretty Horses, Cormac McCarthy writes of “that resonance which is the world itself and which cannot be spoken but only praised.”

In titling her poem “Messenger,” perhaps Oliver sees herself as a kind of John the Baptist, telling us that divinity is at hand. In yielding herself to the perfect whole, to borrow from Ralph Waldo Emerson’s poem “Each and All,” she moves beyond the self that can die and connects with a creation that continues on. Like Blake, she can

See a world in a grain of sand
And a heaven in a wild flower,
Hold infinity in the palm of your hand
And eternity in an hour.

Or as an enchanted Colin exclaims upon first entering the Secret Garden and seeing the magic of green and growing things, “Mary! Dickon! I shall get well! And I shall live forever and ever and ever!”

Here’s Oliver’s poem:

Messenger
by Mary Oliver

My work is loving the world.
Here the sunflowers, there the hummingbird
                   equal seekers of sweetness.
Here the quickening yeast; there the blue plums.
Here the clam deep in the speckled sand.

Are my boots old? Is my coat torn?
Am I no longer young, and still not half-perfect? Let me
                     keep my mind on what matters,
which is my work,

which is mostly standing still and learning to be
                      astonished.
The phoebe, the delphinium.
The sheep in the pasture, and the pasture.
Which is mostly rejoicing, since all the ingredients are here,

which is gratitude, to be given a mind and a heart
                       And these body-clothes,
A mouth with which to give shouts of joy
                       To the moth and the wren, to the sleepy dug-up clam,
Telling them all, over and over,
                        how it is that we live forever.

Wordsworth sums up the experience in Tintern Abbey:

                                    And I have felt
A presence that disturbs me with the joy
Of elevated thoughts; a sense sublime
Of something far more deeply interfused,
Whose dwelling is the light of setting suns,
And the round ocean and the living air,
And the blue sky, and in the mind of man:
A motion and a spirit, that impels
All thinking things, all objects of all thought,
And rolls through all things. 

It is this divine presence that Jesus sought to put us in touch with. He knew that, when we open ourselves to it, everything else falls away. The stone is rolled back and we see into the life of things.

At such moments, shouts of joy. Happy Easter.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , | Comments closed

The Shot Heard Round the World

The Battle at Concord’s Old North Bridge

Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Saturday

Last night 250 years ago, two lanterns in Boston’s North Tower shone out, signaling to Paul Revere and Samuel Dawes that British troops would be crossing the Charles River (“two if by sea”) rather than taking the longer land route (“one if by land”). The following day, exactly 250 years ago, “embattled famers” stood on “the rude bridge that arched the flood” and “fired the shot heard round the world.

In other words, the world witnessed the early stirrings of what would become the American Revolution. “The Declaration of Independence,” signed a little more than a year later, has inspired the cause of freedom ever since.

Over the past few months I’ve written essays on both Henry Wadsworth Longfellow’s “The Midnight Ride of Paul Revere” and Ralph Waldo Emerson’s “The Concord Hymn,” poems which have become terribly relevant. As Americans all over America join “No Kings Day” marches today, I repost the essay on the Emerson poem. Donald Trump is proving far more malicious and far more destructive than George III ever was.

Reprinted from Feb. 24, 2025

Last week Donald Trump tweeted out a picture of himself wearing a crown and proclaiming, “LONG LIVE THE KING!” following his attempt to end Manhattan’s experiment with congestion pricing. While Trump apologists contended that he was just trolling liberals, the declaration is in line with many similar ones, such as that he will be a dictator “on day one,” that “he who saves his Country does not violate any Law,” and (to the governor of Maine) that “We are the federal law.” He might just as well have said, like absolute monarch Louis XIV, “L’état, c’est moi.” [“The state, it is I.”]

“Look at what they do, not what they say,” MSNBC’s Rachel Maddow constantly reminds us, and Trump’s actions since beginning his second term are consistent with one who would like to be king or dictator or a law unto himself. (Especially frightening are his plans for the FBI and the military.) But the king statement has particularly caught people’s attention because, as New Yorker writer Bill McKibben recently observed, Trump is attempting to overturn “the most basic meme in American history.”

Given that the president has us thinking back to George III, it’s time to break out some of our American Revolution-themed poems. Ralph Waldo Emerson’s “Concord Hymn” is a good place to start.

The poem was written in 1837 to dedicate an obelisk erected to commemorate the 1775 Battle of Lexington and Concord. Having heard about stored arms, British troops were on their way to find and destroy them. Thanks to Paul Revere and Samuel Prescott—that’s another poem I may find myself revisiting in the upcoming months—the colonists were warned of their coming. [Note: My post on “The Midnight Ride on Paul Revere can be found here.] Throughout the day, more and more militiamen showed up to harass the British, with the turning point occurring at Concord’s North Bridge, where outnumbered British regulars fell back under intense fire.

Emerson’s poem serves the same purpose as the monument: to make sure that the spirit of those brave men may never be forgotten. After all, memories are short and people pass away. Or as Emerson puts it,

On this green bank, by this soft stream,
    We set to-day a votive stone;
That memory may their deed redeem,
    When, like our sires, our sons are gone.

It is easy to forget the price that people paid for the freedoms we take for granted. Quoting James Marriott of the London times, Heather Cox Richardson has noted that such forgetting—combined with our relatively comfortable lives—is one reason why we’re in our current mess:

[Mariott] noted that the very stability and comfort of the post–World War II liberal order has permitted the seeds of its own destruction to flourish. A society with firm scientific and political guardrails that protect health and freedom, can sustain “an underbelly of madmen and extremists—medical sceptics, conspiracy types and anti-democratic fantasists.”

Marriott continues,

Our society has been peaceful and healthy for so long that for many people serious disaster has become inconceivable. Americans who parade around in amateur militia groups and brandish Nazi symbols do so partly because they are unable to conceive of what life would actually be like in a fascist state.”

He observes that those who are cheering the rise of autocracy in the United States—who are intrigued with having Trump as king or dictator– “have no serious understanding of what it means to live under an autocratic government.”

Someone on Bluesky (I can’t find the reference) noted that something similar happened in Germany’s recent elections, where the extreme right made disturbing gains: bored rich people looking for something to spice up their lives get together in bars and on the internet to bond over hate. They forget that Hitler brought down unthinkable suffering upon the German people, not to mention the rest of the world.

When I was in elementary school, we memorized Emerson’s poem. We should continue having our kids memorize it:

The Concord Hymn
By Ralph Waldo Emerson

By the rude bridge that arched the flood,
    Their flag to April’s breeze unfurled,
Here once the embattled farmers stood,
    And fired the shot heard round the world.

The foe long since in silence slept;
    Alike the conqueror silent sleeps;
And Time the ruined bridge has swept
    Down the dark stream which seaward creeps.

On this green bank, by this soft stream,
    We set to-day a votive stone;
That memory may their deed redeem,
    When, like our sires, our sons are gone.

Spirit, that made those heroes dare
    To die, and leave their children free,
Bid Time and Nature gently spare
    The shaft we raise to them and thee.

As long as Americans remain in touch with that spirit, we will resist Trump’s attempts to restore the monarchy. But it takes courage and constant vigilance to do so.

Added note: Make sure that you check out Heather Cox Richardson’s inspiring account of the events, which emphasizes the importance of small actors. Many of these contribution would be largely forgotten but for Longfellow’s Paul Revere poem.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Comments closed

Good Friday and Imprisoned Immigrants

Giambattista Tiepolo, The Crucifixion

Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Good Friday

George Herbert’s magnificent sonnet “Redemption” is a good poem to read on Good Friday. I thought of it as I was reflecting on how Trump supporters are demonizing Hispanics these days, repeating what the administration says about them being terrorists and gang members. It appears that a mere accusation is all it takes for young Latinos to end up in a Salvadoran concentration camp. Certainly, none are receiving the due process dictated by the Constitution.

El Salvador, ironically, means “The Savior”–a reference to Jesus–and as I read the poem I imagine Christ being carted off to the Centro de Confinamiento del Terrorismo (CECOT). White House spokesperson Levitt and Attorney General Pam Bondi, who often wear gold crosses around their necks, have been making unproven claims about the criminality of many of those sent to CECOT.

In the poem, Herbert describes himself as the struggling tenant of a rich lord. Finding the lord absent from his manor house, he goes looking for him in all the places one would expect to find a rich lord. In the end, however, he finds him amongst thieves and murderers—which is to say, he finds him at the cross:

Redemption
By George Herbert

Having been tenant long to a rich lord,
    Not thriving, I resolvèd to be bold,
    And make a suit unto him, to afford
A new small-rented lease, and cancel th’ old.

In heaven at his manor I him sought;
    They told me there that he was lately gone
    About some land, which he had dearly bought
Long since on earth, to take possessiòn.

I straight returned, and knowing his great birth,
    Sought him accordingly in great resorts;
    In cities, theaters, gardens, parks, and courts;
At length I heard a ragged noise and mirth
         
    Of thieves and murderers; there I him espied,
    Who straight, Your suit is granted, said, and died.

Throughout his poetry, Herbert often agonizes over the fact that he finds it difficult to open his heart to God. (“A heart alone/Is such a stone,” he writes in “The Altar.”) In this poem, he may be referring how he himself once sought worldly advancement “in cities, theaters, gardens, parks, and courts” before becoming an Anglican rector. In any event, he must turn from worldly affairs and find the true heart of Christ if he is to be saved from sin.

The central paradox of Christianity is that God’s divinity was manifested in a lowly human who died a humiliating criminal’s death. It is by identifying with the marginalized and disenfranchised Jesus that Herbert reconnects with his heart. If Herbert were with us today, he would tell us we won’t find God in the halls of power and in the homes of billionaires.

Herbert may have in mind Jesus’s words (Matthew 25:40), “Truly I tell you, whatever you did for one of the least of these brothers and sisters of mine, you did for me.” If only those who wear gold crosses around their necks would open their own hearts.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Comments closed

How Toxic Masculinity Imprisons Men

Jonathan Richardson the Younger, Lady Mary Wortley Montagu

Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Thursday

In her 1991 book Backlash: The Undeclared War Against American Women, Susan Faludi looked at the various ways that men were attempting to undo feminism’s gains. The Trump administration and the modern Republican party appear determined to double down on those efforts, what with firing high-placed women in the government and the military, continuing their assaults on women’s bodily autonomy, and (with the SAVE Act) doing all they can to disenfranchise women voters. And then there’s Elon Musk, who in addition to his drive to impregnate as many women as he can, struck the following macho pose in an e-mail to one of his baby mamas:

In all of history, there has never been a competitive army composed of women. Not even once. Men are made for war. Real men, anyway… I am in full war mode. Going to the front lines today. Must win PA.

The only women that Trump appears to countenance are those who slavishly fawn over him. These he has sprinkled liberally throughout his cabinet.

What misogynists don’t realize—but what authors throughout history have shown—is that toxic masculinity is a guaranteed way of making men permanently anxious and miserable. When a man defines his manhood by his ability to dominate a woman, all a woman has to do is have an affair with another man to destroy his self-worth. This is why, from Chaucer to the 20th century, one finds in literature an obsession with cuckolding jokes. Sexual jokes, so Freud informs us, are a means of finding relief from  our deepest anxieties.

One example of a man caught in the trap of toxic masculinity is the Wife of Bath’s husband #4: when he seeks out other women, she pays him back by messing around herself. “I made him a cross of his own wood,” she declares, and “I made him fry in his own grease.” Another is the husbands and dandies in William Wycherley’s Country Wife, who are so afraid of spousal infidelity that they inadvertently end up pushing their wives into the arms of other men.

One of my favorite examples of an author highlighting how toxic masculinity can rebound on men is Lady Mary Wortley Montau’s “Epistle from Mrs. Yonge to Her Husband.”

In this angry poem, written in 1724 but not published until 1972, Montagu imagines what must be going through the mind of Mary Yonge, estranged wife of William Yonge. Although the two had separated, largely because of his many affairs, when Mary herself took a lover he sued both her and the man. He won both dowry and the bulk of her fortune in the ensuing court case.

Appalled by the double standard, Montagu uses her poem to defend Mary Yonge. Wives have it even worse than servants and slaves, the speaker contends:

All bargains but conditional are made;
The purchase void, the creditor unpaid;
Defrauded servants are from service free;
A wounded slave regains his liberty.
For wives ill used no remedy remains…

To this legal defense, Mary Yonge then adds a plea for understanding:

    And I have borne (oh what have I not borne!)
The pang of jealousy, the insults of scorn.
Wearied at length, I from your sight remove,
And place my future hopes in secret love.

She gets no sympathy from her ex, however:

But you pursue me to this last retreat.
Dragged into light, my tender crime is shown
And every circumstance of fondness known.
Beneath the shelter of the law you stand,
And urge my ruin with a cruel hand…

Although she is ruined by the law and shaken by social exposure, however—her love letters were read aloud in court—Mary Yonge has one consolation: she is free of her tyrannical husband whereas he lives an ever-anxious life. “I prefer this low inglorious state/ To vile dependence on the thing I hate,” she writes, pointing to how he must suck up to the rich and powerful.

His situation is currently being experienced by anyone in Trump’s orbit, including all the members of his cabinet. William Yonge must not only court Prime Minister Walpole but flatter his aging wife:

Go: court the brittle friendship of the great,
Smile at his board, or at his levee wait;
And when dismissed, to madam’s toilet fly,
More than her chambermaids, or glasses, lie,
Tell her how young she looks, how heavenly fair,
Admire the lilies and the roses there.

And now for the kicker. Even if Yonge gets what he wants from all this bootlicking and flattery—he hopes his second wife will be a Walpole cousin with a fortune—their children will not have his genes:

Your high ambition may be gratified,
Some cousin of her own be made your bride,
And you the father of a glorious race
Endowed with Ch——l’s strength and Low——r’s face. 

Montagu herself had had an affair with John Churchill so she knew the man, and Anthony Lowther was a notorious gallant. In other words, the philandering William Yonge can expect to be fried in his own grease by a young second wife.

Epistle from Mrs. Yonge to Her Husband (1724)

Think not this paper comes with vain pretense
To move your pity, or to mourn th’ offense.
Too well I know that hard obdurate heart;
No softening mercy there will take my part,
Nor can a woman’s arguments prevail,
When even your patron’s wise example fails.
But this last privilege I still retain;
Th’ oppressed and injured always may complain.
    Too, too severely laws of honor bind
The weak submissive sex of womankind.
If sighs have gained or force compelled our hand,
Deceived by art, or urged by stern command,
Whatever motive binds the fatal tie,
The judging world expects our constancy.
    Just heaven! (for sure in heaven does justice reign,
Though tricks below that sacred name profane)
To you appealing I submit my cause.
Nor fear a judgment from impartial laws.
All bargains but conditional are made;
The purchase void, the creditor unpaid;
Defrauded servants are from service free;
A wounded slave regains his liberty.
For wives ill used no remedy remains,
To daily racks condemned, and to eternal chains.
    From whence is this unjust distinction grown?
Are we not formed with passions like your own?
Nature with equal fire our souls endued,
Our minds as haughty, and as warm our blood;
O’er the wide world your pleasures you pursue,
The change is justified by something new;
But we must sigh in silence—and be true.
Our sex’s weakness you expose and blame
(Of every prattling fop the common theme),
Yet from this weakness you suppose is due
Sublimer virtue than your Cato knew.
Had heaven designed us trials so severe,
It would have formed our tempers then to bear.
    And I have borne (oh what have I not borne!)
The pang of jealousy, the insults of scorn.
Wearied at length, I from your sight remove,
And place my future hopes in secret love.
In the gay bloom of glowing youth retired,
I quit the woman’s joy to be admired,
With that small pension your hard heart allows,
Renounce your fortune, and release your vows.
To custom (though unjust) so much is due;
I hide my frailty from the public view.
My conscience clear, yet sensible of shame,
My life I hazard, to preserve my fame.
And I prefer this low inglorious state
To vile dependence on the thing I hate—
But you pursue me to this last retreat.
Dragged into light, my tender crime is shown
And every circumstance of fondness known.
Beneath the shelter of the law you stand,
And urge my ruin with a cruel hand,
While to my fault thus rigidly severe,
Tamely submissive to the man you fear.
    This wretched outcast, this abandoned wife,
Has yet this joy to sweeten shameful life:
By your mean conduct, infamously loose,
You are at once my accuser and excuse.
Let me be damned by the censorious prude
(Stupidly dull, or spiritually lewd),
My hapless case will surely pity find
From every just and reasonable mind.
When to the final sentence I submit,
The lips condemn me, but their souls aquit.
    No more my husband, to your pleasures go,
The sweets of your recovered freedom know.
Go: court the brittle friendship of the great,
Smile at his board, or at his levee wait;
And when dismissed, to madam’s toilet fly,
More than her chambermaids, or glasses, lie,
Tell her how young she looks, how heavenly fair,
Admire the lilies and the roses there.
Your high ambition may be gratified,
Some cousin of her own be made your bride,
And you the father of a glorious race
Endowed with Ch——l’s strength and Low——r’s face. 

Back to our current resurgence of toxic masculinity. It wasn’t only women who were liberated by the 1970s feminist movement. Men too had a chance to escape restrictive societal roles. Or putting it positively, we got to explore other sides of ourselves just as women did. Consequently, male-female relationships became more dynamic as couples explored new ways of interacting. Speaking from my own experience with my wife and with female work colleagues, new possibilities arose that made life richer and far more interesting.

Granted, it wasn’t always easy. Centuries-old gender expectations don’t disappear overnight. But the reason that many of us are determined not to go back—men as well as women—is because we would rather experience life in three-dimensional technicolor than one-dimensional black and white. And because toxic masculinity, in addition making one vulnerable to intense anxiety, is so predictable and so dull.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | Comments closed

Imagine the Fall from Eve’s Perspective

Rubens and Brueghel, The Garden of Eden with the Fall of Man

Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Wednesday

Someone on BlueSky recently posted a Danielle Coffyn poem in response to the GOP’s  S.A.V.E. act, recently passed by Republican members of the House. Part of the GOP’s ongoing attempts to disenfranchise as many voters as possible—their constant accusations of (virtually non-existent) voter fraud are designed to justify their own (very real) voter suppression efforts—SAVE would require voters to show a a birth certificate, U.S. passport, naturalization paperwork, or certain versions of the Read ID that indicate citizenship. As an NPR article points out,

[F]or as many as 69 million American women who have taken on their spouse’s name, their birth certificates no longer match the names they use today, according to an analysis by the progressive Center for American Progress. Meanwhile, more than half of all Americans do not have a passport, according to a 2023 YouGov survey.

While it is true that Republican women as well as Democratic women would be impacted by the law, Republicans probably see them as necessary collateral damage in the attempt to reduce the overall number of women voting, given that more women vote Democratic than Republican. This is certainly true of poor women voters, who are less likely to have any of the documents required.

And of course, there’s Peter Thiel, the Trump-supporting billionaire who doesn’t believe that women should have the right to vote in the first place.

The good news is that Democrats in the Senate will probably filibuster the bill. Still, like GOP efforts to assert control over women’s bodily autonomy, the SAVE act reveals Republicans’ patriarchal ambitions.

With that in mind, here’s Coffyn’s poem:

If Adam Picked the Apple
By Danielle Coffyn

There would be a parade,
a celebration,
a holiday to commemorate
the day he sought enlightenment.
We would not speak of
temptation by the devil, rather,
we would laud Adam’s curiosity,
his desire for adventure
and knowing.
We would feast
on apple-inspired fare:
tortes, chutneys, pancakes, pies.
There would be plays and songs
reenacting his courage.
 
But it was Eve who grew bored,
weary of her captivity in Eden.
And a woman’s desire
for freedom is rarely a cause
for celebration.

Note: As much as I love Paradise Lost, which includes Eve complaining that God “forbids us to be wise,” Milton’s division of men and women into thinkers and feelers reenforces the stereotype that underlie GOP patriarchal assumptions. When angels are sent to Eden to deliver TED talks on the origins of the universe and what is to come, they speak only to Adam. For her part, Eve is sent away before Raphael warns Adam about Satan, and she is sedated before Michael foretells human history. While she is depicted as more intuitive than Adam, Reason is clearly man’s domain.

Let’s just say that the GOP at the moment is being guided more by emotion than by Reason.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | Comments closed

MAGA Reenacts Enslavement of Joseph

Bartolomé Estaban Murillo, Joseph and His Brethren

Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Tuesday

As Jewish families and communities come together this week to relive the escape from Egyptian slavery, I am struck by how Trump’s America is reenacting the Joseph story. Just as Joseph’s deeply resentful brothers sold him into bondage, so “Mass Deportation Now” Republicans are celebrating as innocent immigrants are deported to foreign dungeons.

Nobel laureate Issac Bashevis Singer has ranked “the sublime scribe of the Joseph story” with Chekhov and Maupassant as masters of the short story form. One can read these authors “over and over again and never get bored,” Singer says. Here’s the part of the story that aligns with ICE kidnapping Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia and other  immigrants:

Now Israel loved Joseph more than any of his other sons, because he had been born to him in his old age; and he made an ornate robe for him. When his brothers saw that their father loved him more than any of them, they hated him and could not speak a kind word to him.

Joseph had a dream, and when he told it to his brothers, they hated him all the more. He said to them, “Listen to this dream I had: We were binding sheaves of grain out in the field when suddenly my sheaf rose and stood upright, while your sheaves gathered around mine and bowed down to it.”

His brothers said to him, “Do you intend to reign over us? Will you actually rule us?” And they hated him all the more because of his dream and what he had said….

So Joseph went after his brothers and found them near Dothan. But they saw him in the distance, and before he reached them, they plotted to kill him.

“Here comes that dreamer!” they said to each other. “Come now, let’s kill him and throw him into one of these cisterns and say that a ferocious animal devoured him. Then we’ll see what comes of his dreams”….

So when Joseph came to his brothers, they stripped him of his robe—the ornate robe he was wearing— and they took him and threw him into the cistern. The cistern was empty; there was no water in it.

As they sat down to eat their meal, they looked up and saw a caravan of Ishmaelites coming from Gilead. Their camels were loaded with spices, balm and myrrh, and they were on their way to take them down to Egypt.

Judah said to his brothers, “What will we gain if we kill our brother and cover up his blood? Come, let’s sell him to the Ishmaelites and not lay our hands on him; after all, he is our brother, our own flesh and blood.” His brothers agreed.

So when the Midianite merchants came by, his brothers pulled Joseph up out of the cistern and sold him for twenty shekelsof silver to the Ishmaelites, who took him to Egypt.

Modern day Ishmaelites—in this case, Salvadoran president Nayib Bukele—are getting both the slave and the money ($20,000 a year for each prisoner sent).

The resentment that Donald Trump has stoked against immigrants is all there in the story. Many white Americans are convinced that immigrants are getting preferential treatment and that they operate with a Josephian sense of entitlement. (Following last week’s Hands Off demonstration I encountered a woman who told me that immigrants don’t have to pay taxes for their first six years.) In their fear and anger, they are more than willing to see them carted off to inhumane conditions.

In the post I wrote following that demonstration, I reported on how the Norman Rockwell Saturday Evening Post covers of the 1950s and 1960s–which feature kindly cops, Boy Scouts, shy teachers, solicitous soldiers, kindly Santas, etc.–assured my childhood self that Americans are fundamentally decent people. It is a foundational belief of many liberals that our better angels (to borrow from Lincoln) will ultimately prevail. But what if this belief is wrong? I didn’t mention that virtually all the figures in Rockwell’s paintings of small town life—from 1916 until 1964—are white. Only when his own assumptions about Americans were shaken to the core by southern racist violence did Rockwell change. (His famous The Problem We All Live With shows six-year-old Ruby Bridges going to school flanked by four U.S. marshals.)

Because of bipartisan support of civil rights in the 1960s (if one excludes the south), liberals felt that we could in fact step into our better selves. But instead of northern liberals changing the south, it now appears that southern intolerance has infected a significant sector of the north, with Confederate flags now a not uncommon sign in former Union states. Political scientist John Stoehr writes that, just as liberals “grossly underestimate the power of corruption, greed, arrogance and stupidity,” so do they “grossly overestimate the inherent goodness of the American people”:

White liberals seem naive about the current character of the American people, because most are living in the past. In the postwar era, there was a consensus about the government, that it should serve everyone, and from that arose all the rights movements. After four decades of rightwing propaganda, that consensus is gone.

And yet, Stoehr concludes, liberals keep clinging to their naiveté.

To be sure, not everyone has had our illusions about this “inherent goodness.” I’m currently on a Louise Erdrich kick, and there are few novels where the Chippewa author doesn’t mention past White atrocities, whether in the form of bounties for Indian scalps, massacres, land grabs, and the like. But with the rise of rights movements of the 1970s, there was reason to hope that the worst was behind us.

Now that faith has been shaken.

So where does that leave us now? It is up to us to resist Trumpian intolerance in whatever forms it takes. “Hope never never came from people who succumbed to evil,” Stoehr writes. “It comes from people who can face evil squarely in the face and then act accordingly.”

Passover is a time to face up to evil and then remind ourselves that hope has triumphed in the past and can do so again. Back in 2011 I shared Primo Levi’s “Passover,” which is so beloved that it has been incorporated into many people’s seder rituals. As an Auschwitz survivor, Levi knew at a deep, deep level what it means to become a demonized Other.

Each of us has been a slave in Egypt,
Soaked straw and clay with sweat,
And crossed the sea dry-footed.
You too, stranger.

And then there’s the Adam Zagajewski Passover poem I shared in 2023, which alerts us to the plight of the world’s refugees:  

You’ve seen the refugees going nowhere,
you’ve heard the executioners sing joyfully.
You should praise the mutilated world.

I fear for the souls of those who sign on to Trump’s bigotry and rejoice over his cruelties. All those politicians, spokespeople, Cabinet officials, lawyers, ICE members, bureaucrats, and other supporters are being hollowed out by the hate. While Passover cannot change the world’s injustices, it gives us a chance to ground ourselves in what is right and true.

Or as Levi concludes his poem,

This year in fear and shame,
Next year in virtue and in justice.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | Comments closed

On Deportations and an Oz Book

John R. Neill, King Gos and Queen Cor bribe the nome king to imprison innocent captives in Rinki-Tink in Oz

Note: If you wish to receive, via e-mail, (1) my weekly newsletter or (2) daily copies of these posts, write to me at rrbates1951@gmail.com. Comments may also be sent to this address. I promise not to share your e-mail with anyone. To unsubscribe, write here as well.

Monday

The Kakaesque horror of Trump’s deportation of immigrants to a Salvadoran hellhole, including (thanks to an admitted “administrative error”) legal U.S. resident Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia, demonstrates that George Orwell should have added 40 years to his masterwork. Can we retitle it 2025 and note that it is no longer predicting a dystopian future but describing a present-day reality? And will we ever wake up from this nightmare?

As I was reading about these deportations to El Salvador, I started experiencing an unsettling sense of familiarity. Something similar happens in one of my favorite Oz books, L. Frank Baum’s Rinki-Tink in Oz.

I vividly remember, as a child, reading about the seizure of the king and queen of Pingaree by ruthless raiders from the twin island of Regos and Coregos. When Prince Inga, aided by three magical pearls that give him strength, protection, and advice, goes to free his parents, they are deported carried to the prison of a foreign dictator. In return for a substantial bribe, Nome King Kaliko agrees to hold them as indefinite prisoners in his underground prisons.

In light of recent events, I am almost as disturbed by rereading the episode now as I was when I read the book at age 10 or so.

After Inga, aided by the pearls, invades the islands, Queen Cor figures they must use the boy’s parents as hostages:

We must take the boy’s parents away from here as quickly as possible. I have with me the Queen of Pingaree, and you can run up to the mines and get the King. Then we will carry them away in a boat and hide them where the boy cannot find them, with all his magic. We will use the King and Queen of Pingaree as hostages, and send word to the boy wizard that if he does not go away from our islands and allow us to rule them undisturbed, in our own way, we will put his father and mother to death. Also we will say that as long as we are let alone his parents will be safe, although still safely hidden. I believe, Gos, that in this way we can compel Prince Inga to obey us, for he seems very fond of his parents.

Their plan is to send them to the novel’s version of a Salvadoran prison:

“It isn’t a bad idea,” said Gos, reflectively; “but where can we hide the King and Queen, so that the boy cannot find them?”

“In the country of the Nome King, on the mainland away at the south,” she replied. “The nomes are our friends, and they possess magic powers that will enable them to protect the prisoners from discovery.”

Thanks to advice from his wisdom pearl, Inga tracks his parents to the nome king’s realm, only to encounter a ruler using the logic presently being used by El Salvador’s president Nayib Bukele. Bukele is being paid $20,000 a year per inmate he takes in, and Nome King Kaliko is similarly transactional. As he explains to the king and queen of Pingaree when they protest their innocence and charge Gos and Cor of lying about them,

I know it. I consider it a clever lie, though, because it is woven without a thread of truth. However, that is none of my business. The fact remains that my good friend King Gos wishes to put you in my underground caverns, so that you will be unable to escape. And why should I not please him in this little matter? Gos is a mighty King and a great warrior, while your island of Pingaree is desolated and your people scattered. In my heart, King Kitticut, I sympathize with you, but as a matter of business policy we powerful Kings must stand together and trample the weaker ones under our feet…. The fact that you are a prisoner, my poor Kitticut, is evidence that you are weaker than King Gos, and I prefer to deal with the strong.

Bukele is operating similarly. He knows perfectly well that many of the prisoners being sent to him (those not taken directly out of U.S. prisons) are innocent of gang membership. But as Jonathan V. Last of the Bulwark observes,

Let us speak plainly: Nayib Bukele is a minor strongman who will do whatever Donald Trump demands of him. If Trump wants Abrego Garcia in the United States, then Bukele will return him. By the same token, if Bukele understands that Trump does not want Abrego Garcia returned, then he will keep the man.

Bukele has no interests in this game other than pleasing his political patron. His exercise of Salvadoran “sovereignty” can only be read as an expression of Donald Trump’s will.

Anyone who asserts otherwise is either a villain or a fool.

So if Bukele affirmatively refuses to repatriate Abrego Garcia, it will mean that Trump has told him not to.

I suspect, however, that Bukele does not talk as frankly to Trump as Kaliko talks to the rulers of the twin islands. “In spite of your false statements and misrepresentations,” he tells them, “I will earn the treasure you have brought me, by keeping your prisoners safe in my caverns.”

Heaven knows what will happen to Abrego Garcia and the others illegally sent to foreign prisons without a chance to appeal their cases. In the novel there’s a deus ex machina ending that I found disappointing as a child. Dorothy, now a princess in Oz, has been keeping track of events through Glinda’s magical Great Book of Records, “wherein is inscribed all important events that happen in every part of the world.” When she learns about Inga, she gets Ozma’s permission to intervene.

She shows up in Kaliko’s realm with a basket of eggs, which the nomes find to be toxic, and demands that he release Inga’s parents. Kaliko at first argues that he has to honor his contract. In this, he sounds a bit like the Trump administration, which is contending that it is no longer “custodian”:

“I can’t do it, Dorothy,” said the Nome King, almost weeping with despair. “I promised King Gos I’d keep them captives. You wouldn’t ask me to break my promise, would you?”

Dorothy replies,

“King Gos was a robber and an outlaw, and p’r’aps you don’t know that a storm at sea wrecked his boat, while he was going back to Regos, and that he and Queen Cor were both drowned.

So between being offered this out and threatened with eggs (presumably purchased at non-inflationary prices), Kaliko frees the king and queen of Pingaree.

Right now, the only hope of those imprisoned is the U.S. Court System. Can judges compel Trump to release people who have been deported to foreign jails? Or will they prove less powerful than Ozma and her emissary Dorothy? We don’t yet know the answer.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Comments closed

  • Sign up for my weekly newsletter