Ishiguro on the Challenges of Mimicry

Thursday

One of my Postcolonial Literature students is writing on Kazuo Ishiguro’s Klara and the Sun, and the more we talk, the more interesting I find the novel to be.

At first I wondered whether it would fit the course since neither England nor Japan colonized the other. Indeed, an Indian reader sent me an article recently in which the author imagines an alternate history for India: rather than modernizing the country, what if England hampered it through conquest. After all, Japan did very well for itself without being occupied by a colonial power. True, it was forced into modernity by western powers, but after that, it figured out things for itself.

But returning to Ishiguro, the postcolonial concepts of hybridity and mimicry apply nicely to his works. For instance, we see characters engaged in various forms of mimicry in the following works:

–in Remains of the Day, the butler seeks to be the perfect servant butler, even though it means denying his humanity in the process;
–in Never Let Me Go, the clones think of themselves as real people, even though they have only been engineered to supply replacement organs for others;
–in Klara and the Sun, a care robot is instructed to resemble a child so that she can replace the girl when she dies.

I can imagine why mimicry would be an important theme for Ishiguro. Having moved with his family to England at age six, he must have struggled to fit in with his classmates. While he might have thought of himself as English, he would have been perceived as having a hybrid Anglo-Japanese identity.

His sci-fi novels in which engineered humans struggle with being partly machine, partly human, allow him to explore his own identity struggles.

He has chosen his issue well because hybrid-identities are becoming increasingly common in our globalized world. I expect that many of the rightwing nationalist movements have anxiety about this issue at their very core, including white nationalists in America and Slovenian nationalist where I am presently. (Slovenia’s current rightwing president is a Trump fan.)

I now understand why, last time I was here a Slovenian-Serbian student found her own identity struggle depicted in Klara. Carrying as she did a Serbian last name, she encountered anti-Serb prejudice but had a chance (or so she thought) to remove the stigma if she took the Slovenian name of her fiancé. She hesitated making the move, however, because she worried that, by fitting in seamlessly, she would be sacrificing some essential part of herself. 

The book asks whether one can in fact fit in seamlessly. By choosing to make the narrator a robot, Ishiguo dramatizes the issue. The book features a girl, Josie, who is dying because her parents (Chrissie and Paul) chose to have her neurologically enhanced (“lifted”) so that she would be able to compete in an increasingly competitive world. The operation carries risks and Josie is bedridden. To keep her company, her parents buy her Klara, an AF or Artificial Friend.

The mother has a secondary agenda. Having already lost one child because of the lifting process, she wants Klara to become Josie so that she will have a replacement for Josie should Josie die.

Because she is a robot, Klara believes she can do it since she is continually evolving:

As I say, these were helpful lessons for me [interacting with Josie]. Not only had I learnt that changes were a part of Josie, and that I should be ready to accommodate them, I’d begun to understand also, that this wasn’t a trait peculiar just to Josie, that people often felt the need to prepare a side of themselves to display to passersby – as they might in a store window, and that such display needn’t be taken so seriously once the moment had passed.

Klara has a number of in-depth conversations with the father, who opposes his wife’s plan to create a second Josie but feels he can’t stop it. At one point he asks Klara whether she can capture Josie’s heart. Klara responds,

It might indeed be the hardest part of Josie to learn. It might be like a house with many rooms. Even so, a devoted AF, given time, could walk through each of those rooms, studying them carefully in turn, until they became like her own home.

Paul has doubts, responding,

But then suppose you stepped into one of those rooms and discovered another room within it. And inside that room, another room still. Rooms within rooms within rooms. Isn’t that how it might be, trying to learn Josie’s heart? No matter how long you wandered through those rooms, wouldn’t there always be others you’d not yet entered?”

He acknowledges, however, that he might be wrong. Talking of the engineer who has talked his wife in creating a Josie 2.0,  he observes,

I think I hate Capaldi because deep down I suspect he may be right. That what he claims is true. That science has now proved beyond doubt there’s nothing so unique about my daughter, nothing there our modern tools can’t excavate, copy, transfer. That people have been living with one another all this time, centuries, loving and hating each other, and all on a mistaken premise. A kind of superstition we kept going while we didn’t know better.

And later:

Our generation still carry the old feelings. A part of us refuses to let go. The part that wants to keep believing there’s something unreachable inside each of us. Something that’s unique and won’t transfer. But there’s nothing like that, we know that now. You know that. For people our age it’s a hard one to let go.

It is Klara herself, however, that realizes that she will never be able to duplicate Josie. Whatever was special about Josie, she says, was not inside Josie but inside those who loved her. Humans are not stand-alone units but a network of relationships. Klara comes to this realization after Josie has recovered and she herself has been disposed of in a graveyard for robots whose solar batteries are running out. She tells this to the store manager who originally sold her and who has set up the graveyard:

Manager, I did all I could to learn Josie and had it become necessary, I would have done my utmost. But I don’t think it would have worked out so well. Not because I wouldn’t have achieved accuracy. But however hard I tried, I believe now there would have remained something beyond my reach. The Mother, Rick, Melania Housekeeper, the Father. I’d never have reached what they felt for Josie in their hearts. I’m now sure of this, Manager.

I wonder if my Serbian-Slovenian student sensed this when she chose to keep her Serbian name: that her identity wasn’t only about her but about others who knew her. The same is true for minorities and new immigrant groups who desire to erase their previous identities. Those in America who desire to “become white”—who attempt to cut themselves off from their communities and families and histories—will always be defined by those networks even in the act of rejecting them.

In the worst cases—I think of Stephen Miller, whose ancestors came to America fleeing eastern European pogroms–they feel they must prove to themselves they belong by embracing draconian measures against others seeking to become American. They are so fearful of not fitting in that they become fanatical.

Postcolonialist theory has another concept—ambivalence—that gets at this inner turmoil. One sees it also in a figure like Supreme Court Justice Clarence Thomas, an African American who has spent his entire time on the court ruling against Civil Rights measures. His life and his legacy have been defined by rejection.

One last thought: As I talked to my students about their essays, I pointed out how Ishiguro’s book also had something to say about the use of AI. It’s not only that an AI generated paper will deprive them of the learning and the brain growth that comes with struggling to develop one’s ideas, I told them. They will also be denying their own heart and their own humanity, becoming instead undifferentiated replicas. My daughter-in-law, a film studies professor, has received some of these essays and talks about how deadening they are.

In a world filled with large classes and grade pressures, it can be difficult to persuade students that they owe it to Self and Soul to grapple with ideas the hard way. A novel like Klara and the Sun can help a teacher make the case.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | Leave a comment

King Lear on Trump’s Underlings

Kent takes on Oswald

Wednesday

Teaching King Lear yesterday, I was particularly struck by how much Shakespeare explores followers willing to sacrifice themselves for higher ideals. As the Democrats draw up plans to investigate the White House’s rampant corruption, we can use the play to differentiate four different ways that underlings have responded to DJT’s misbehavior. Here they are:

Kent: The loyal retainer who has sworn allegiance to the monarchy as well as to the monarch and so doesn’t hesitate to speak truth to Lear when Lear falls short of his kingly responsibilities.

Cornwall’s Servant #1: Although this servant has served Cornwall (and now his wife Regan) faithfully, he is appalled by how his master is torturing Gloucester for his loyalty to Lear. When Cornwall begins to pry out Gloucester’s eyes with his knife (“Out, vile jelly!”), this servant rebels and fights his master.

Cornwall’s Servants #2, #3, and #4: While these don’t confront Cornwall, they commiserate with Gloucester and support him after he has been blinded.

Oswald: The ultimate sycophant, Oswald does whatever dirty work Goneril and Regan want while adding in his own dish of arrogance.

Let’s look at each one in turn.

Kent is like the NeverTrumpers who, despite their loyalty to the GOP, took principled stands after Trump attempted a coup (and some earlier). Liz Cheney and Adam Kissinger, two very conservative Republicans, served on the Congressional committee investigating the coup and both paid for it electorally. I imagine Cheney delivering Kent’s speech after Lear attacks him for defending Cordelia. For “Royal Lear,” however, imagine her saying, “Constitution”:

KENT Royal Lear,
Whom I have ever honour’d as my king,
Loved as my father, as my master follow’d,
As my great patron thought on in my prayers,–

KING LEAR The bow is bent and drawn, make from the shaft.

KENT Let it fall rather, though the fork invade
The region of my heart: be Kent unmannerly,
When Lear is mad. What wilt thou do, old man?
Think’st thou that duty shall have dread to speak,
When power to flattery bows? To plainness honour’s bound,
When majesty stoops to folly. Reverse thy doom;
And, in thy best consideration, cheque
This hideous rashness: answer my life my judgment,
Thy youngest daughter does not love thee least…

When Lear threatens Kent with death, Kent responds,

My life I never held but as a pawn
To wage against thy enemies; nor fear to lose it,
Thy safety being the motive.

And when Lear lays his hand upon his sword, Kent responds,

Do:
Kill thy physician, and the fee bestow
Upon thy foul disease. Revoke thy doom;
Or, whilst I can vent clamour from my throat,
I’ll tell thee thou dost evil.

And finally, after Lear banishes him:

Fare thee well, king: sith thus thou wilt appear,
Freedom lives hence, and banishment is here.

Banishment for such as Cheney, Kissinger, and a host of others would have been continuing to serve in the White House. Only by challenging the king did they find true freedom. Furthermore, many of these figures have continued to serve the republic, just as Kent continues to serve Lear, albeit in disguise.

First Servant

The first servant objects after Cornwall has gorged out one of Gloucester’s eyes and is preparing to take out the second. He could be any of those Republicans who spoke out against Trump, either in the impeachment trials or in the Congressional investigation. Alex Vindman and Cassidy Hutchinson come to mind but there are many others.

Note how the man tells Cornwall that he has never done him “better service” than now when he bids him to hold back. Needless to say, neither Cornwall nor Regan see it that way:

First Servant Hold your hand, my lord:
I have served you ever since I was a child;
But better service have I never done you
Than now to bid you hold.

REGAN How now, you dog!

First Servant If you did wear a beard upon your chin,
I’d shake it on this quarrel. What do you mean?

CORNWALL My villain!
They draw and fight

First Servant Nay, then, come on, and take the chance of anger.

REGAN Give me thy sword. A peasant stand up thus!
Takes a sword, and runs at him behind

First Servant O, I am slain! My lord, you have one eye left
To see some mischief on him. O!
Dies

While he fails to save Gloucester, the servant doesn’t sacrifice his life for naught. Cornwall too dies, the first of the scoundrels to face accountability, and his death indirectly sets in motion the deaths of Regan and Goneril. At the very least, it reminds us that barbarity does not escape notice and judgment.

Second, Third, and Fourth Servants

There are still staff members in the various governmental departments—fewer all the time but still some—who strive to keep their institutions running. They are as anonymous as Cornwall’s servants and not as brave as Servant #1, but they may serve important roles as whistle blowers when investigators come knocking. Already some of them have reported that people around Trump are destroying documents in an effort to cover malfeasance. The “Bedlam” in the following passage is Gloucester’s son Edgar, whose disguise as a madman will allow him to escape detection (“his roguish madness allows itself to anything”):

Second Servant I’ll never care what wickedness I do,
If this man come to good.

Third Servant If she live long,
And in the end meet the old course of death,
Women will all turn monsters.

Second Servant Let’s follow the old earl, and get the Bedlam
To lead him where he would: his roguish madness
Allows itself to anything.

Third Servant Go thou: I’ll fetch some flax and whites of eggs
To apply to his bleeding face. Now, heaven help him!
Exeunt severally

Oswald

Oswald stands in for the most recognizable figures in Trump’s cabinet, starting with J.D. Vance and going on down. Oswald will do anything for Regan and Goneril, most notably attempting to kill Gloucester. Edgar, after killing him, describes him as

                 a serviceable villain;
As duteous to the vices of thy mistress
As badness would desire.

The best description of his type comes from Kent, who recognizes in him the polar opposite of himself. I see Shakespeare channeling his own fury at the sycophants of his day in Kent’s speech. For my part, I too read it with particular satisfaction when I imagine directing it at Trump’s enablers. Don’t worry if you fail to understand many of the insults since “son and heir of a mongrel bitch” captures the spirit of the whole:

KENT Fellow, I know thee.

OSWALD What dost thou know me for?

KENT A knave; a rascal; an eater of broken meats; a base, proud, shallow, beggarly, three-suited, hundred-pound, filthy, worsted-stocking knave; a lily-livered, action-taking knave, a whoreson, glass-gazing, super-serviceable finical rogue;one-trunk-inheriting slave; one that wouldst be a bawd, in way of good service, and art nothing but the composition of a knave, beggar, coward, pandar, and the son and heir of a mongrel bitch: one whom I will beat into clamorous whining, if thou deniest the least syllable of thy addition.

I would so enjoy delivering these words to Pete Hegseth or Marco Rubio. “I know you for…!”

While I’m on the subject of self-serving scoundrels, I should mention Edmund. Like DJT, he too is contemptuous of custom and he too makes nature—which is to say, his desires—his law. Note his contempt for legitimacy:

As to the legitimate: fine word,–legitimate!
Well, my legitimate, if this letter speed,
And my invention thrive, Edmund the base
Shall top the legitimate. I grow; I prosper:
Now, gods, stand up for bastards!

Edmund is speaking of Edgar, who is Gloucester’s legitimate heir, but “legitimate” could refer to any proper observance of the law. Lawlessness overwhelms the forces of good in this drama so that, in addition to Cordelia being killed and Lear dying, good men like Albany and Kent are broken by the end. Edgar is the only one left to reunite a kingdom that an old man, in his dotage, has torn apart in Shakespeare’s bleakest ending.

Fortunately, with the recent elections, America has a chance to repair the damage. Restoring the republic, however, will require accessing our inner Kent.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

MAGA’s Golden Calf

Gold-plated statue of Trump at Mar-a-Lago

Tuesday

If Texas went blue this past election—and in the process unexpectedly chose a Latina as its governor—it’s in part because Latinos were horrified by their white evangelical neighbors. According to the Contrarian, a recently-released American Values survey revealed that “white evangelical Protestants (53 percent) are the only religious group where the majority agree with placing undocumented immigrants into internment camps until they can be deported.” 

Milton would have something to say about this. Dante as well. More on them in a moment.

The values study didn’t look only at attitudes towards immigrants but at empathy in general. While 68 percent of Americans say that empathy is “a foundational moral value that helps build a healthy society,” 27% say that it becomes dangerous “when it leads people away from building a society guided by God’s truth.” White evangelical Protestants, the study went on to report, “are the only religious group in which a majority does not agree that empathy is a foundational moral value.” Only 42 percent agreed while 54 percent disagreed.

In the final book of Paradise Lost, the archangel Michael informs Adam about what happens when self-proclaimed Christians stray from God’s word:

Wolves shall succeed for teachers, grievous wolves,
Who all the sacred mysteries of Heaven
To their own vile advantages shall turn
Of lucre and ambition; and the truth
With superstitions and traditions taint…

Milton particularly singles out those who compromise their faith for political power:

Then shall they seek to avail themselves of names,
Places, and titles, and with these to join
Secular power; though feigning still to act
By spiritual…

Milton notes that, though these wolves will follow “outward rites,” truth and works of faith will be absent:

[T]he rest, far greater part,
Will deem in outward rites and specious forms
Religion satisfied; Truth shall retire
Bestuck with slanderous darts, and works of faith
Rarely be found: So shall the world go on,
To good malignant, to bad men benign;
Under her own weight groaning…

So what about the man whom so many white evangelicals have made their idol? In his recent 60 Minutes interview with the Catholic conservative Ross Douthat, our president provided us with a textbook example of how Dante’s Inferno works.

Those who are in hell, Dante emphasizes, have chosen on their own accord to cut themselves off from God’s love. The torments that the damned undergo are reenactments of the inner hells they created for themselves while still alive. Charles Dickens too captures the dynamic in the figure of Marley:

I wear the chain I forged in life. I made it link by link, and yard by yard; I girded it on my own free will, and of my own free will I wore it.

Scrooge is living a hell on earth until his heart opens to the spirit of Christmas. At that point his life becomes heaven.

In the CBS interview, we see Trump using his own free will to choose hell. I quote CBS’s account at length because Trump’s admission is so extraordinary:

When asked what he thinks happens when he dies, Mr. Trump told Douthat, “I’m a religious person, so in theory, I go to heaven.”

Douthat posed the question: “Let’s say you pass away, you’re entering the next life, and all you have to do to enter paradise is feel love and forgiveness for James Comey, Nancy Pelosi, anyone who you have expressed hate for over the years. Do you think you can do it?”

“Well, then I wouldn’t be real, would I?” Mr. Trump said, calling them “extremely dishonest people, very bad people, very bad for our country.”

Douthat asked: “Is the answer no, then?”

“The answer is no. I want to be honest, no,” Trump replied.

Douthat continued: “Mr. President, you have had the most charmed and remarkable life of any American in my entire lifetime, and you are telling me that before the judgment throne of God, you couldn’t find it in your heart to forgive some of your enemies? After all that’s been given to you?”

“Can I be honest?” Trump asked. “I probably cannot do that, no, because I do hate some of my enemies, and I always will.”

Dante shows us what “always” looks like.

But forget about the afterlife. Can there be any doubt that Trump has chosen hell in the here and now? As have those Christians who worship him with all their heart, soul, and mind while refusing to love their neighbors as themselves.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

My Better Living Project Summarized

Monday

I had a lovely opportunity Friday to share my approach to literature with an American poetry class at the University of Maribor, the second largest university in Slovenia. For people new to this blog or unfamiliar with my approach, I share it here as a quick overview. 

I entitled my talk Poetry as an Indispensable Life Companion: People “Die Miserably Every Day” without It. The allusion is to a passage by the Modernist American poet William Carlos Williams:

it is difficult
to get the news from poems
yet men die miserably every day
for lack
of what is found there 

Williams, I noted, was in a defensive crouch. Poetry was deemed irrelevant by many in pragmatic 1950s America. He imagines people dismissing poetry because it doesn’t address current topics and responds by making the best case he can for poetry’s relevance.

His fear was not new. I did a quick survey of others throughout the ages who have called poetry irrelevant. Here are some of the most notable instances:

–Plato was prepared to ban poetry from his ideal republic unless it could prove itself socially useful. “Poetry must “show not only that she is pleasant but also useful to states and to human life,” he wrote. Neither Hesiod nor Homer fit his criteria;
–The Roman poet Horace noted that grumpy old men only like poetry that is edifying, thereby alienating entertainment-seeking young men. The best poetry, he concluded, is poetry that is useful and entertaining;
–The 16th century Puritan writer Stephen Gossen said that poetry was “unprofitable” and a waste of time, thereby triggering Sir Philip Sidney’s famous essay “Defense of Poesie”;
–In 1802, Romantic poet William Wordsworth worried that poetry was becoming “a thing as indifferent” as a taste for rope dancing or sherry;
–In 1821 Thomas Peacock light-heartedly argued that poetry was in decline, bypassed by new scientific and technological breakthroughs. The essay triggered Percy Shelley’s famous Defence of Poetry;
–At the end of the 19th century, worried about people who made utilitarian arguments for art, Oscar Wilde famously said, “All art is quite useless.” (He also wrote “The Soul of Man under Socialism,” which contradicts this.)
–In his poem “Adam’s Curse,” William Butler Yeats wrote that the poet who articulates “sweet sounds together” is considered to be an idler

                               by the noisy set
Of bankers, schoolmasters, and clergymen   
The martyrs call the world.

–In his poem “In Memory of W.B. Yeats,” W.H. Auden famously wrote that “poetry makes nothing happen,” at least in the eyes of “executives.”

At this point, however, I mentioned that one of Auden’s own poems made something happen for Americans on September 11, 2001. On a day when America was reeling from the attacks on the Twin Towers, Scott Simon of National Public Radio read excerpts from Auden’s “September 1, 1939,” written in response to Hitler’s invasion of Poland. Many found the poem articulated their uncertainty and pain while offering them solace, especially the final stanza:

Defenceless under the night
Our world in stupor lies;
Yet, dotted everywhere,
Ironic points of light
Flash out wherever the Just
Exchange their messages:
May I, composed like them
Of Eros and of dust,
Beleaguered by the same
Negation and despair,
Show an affirming flame.

Nevertheless, far too many agree with Gossen’s contention that poetry is unprofitable and a waste of time. This, I told the class, led to my blog and my book.

Explaining that I have always been fascinated by how literature enters people’s lives, I discussed the difficulty of making general statements about literary impact. After all, literary response is subjective, with different individuals often having widely different experiences with the same work. I therefore shared my two ways of exploring the question:

#1: By writing a daily blog in which I examine how I am using literature that day, I have an on-going record of how I–and sometimes others–use literature. Perhaps I can capture over time what I cannot sum up in an essay or book.

#2: I survey what many of the world’s great thinkers have said about literature impacting lives. While there are a range of theories, at least we can get a sense of the possibilities.

To give my blog and then my book a title, I borrowed from a Dupont Chemicals ad campaign in the middle decades of the 20th century. In other words, I pushed against a pragmatism that deems poetry to be non-essential by going into the heart of the beast. Because it had invented polyester fabrics, nylon stockings, and cellophane (among other things), Dupont could proudly proclaim

BETTER THINGS FOR BETTER LIVING . . . THROUGH CHEMISTRY

I figured I would dramatically make my point by ironically juxtaposing something authentic (literature) with something utterly inauthentic (plastic). I sought to refute the enemy on the enemy’s own turf.

I shared with the students several personal examples of literature leading to better living, all of which have appeared in my blog and in my book. They included:

–how I used Huckleberry Finn to find my center in the civil rights battles I experienced as a middle schooler;
–how Sir Gawain and the Green Knight helped an Afghanistan War vet in one of my classes to recognize and begin working with some PTSD he had picked up from defusing roadside bombs;
–how I would often turn to Beowulf to explore mass killings in America and around the world since, like Grendel, the murderers are often driven by resentment.

 I then gave the class a brief summation of some of what some of history’s great minds have said about literary impact:

–Plato feared that dramatic poetry corrupted young men;
–Aristotle saw the same poetry training citizens in leadership;
–Horace saw poetry as the best way to deliver life lessons;
–Sir Philip Sidney believed that poetry inculcated virtue;
–Samuel Johnson feared that novels corrupted young people;
–Percy Shelley believed poetry helped free slaves and women;
–John Stuart Mill believed poetry gave our lives meaning;
–Marx and Engels believed novels could serve human liberation;
–Du Bois, Brecht, Marcuse, Fanon, Jameson, Eagleton agreed;
–Modern feminists are ambivalent;
–Freud and Jung believed that novels and poetry could heal us;
–Wayne Booth and Martha Nussbaum believe great lit makes us better people and better voters;
–American cultural conservatives believe the classics hold off the barbarians at the gates.

This I followed with quotations from my own two favorite theorists:

–It exceeds all imagination to conceive what would have been the moral condition of the world if neither Dante, Petrarch, Boccaccio, Chaucer, Shakespeare, Calderon, Lord Bacon, nor Milton, had ever existed; if Raphael and Michael Angelo had never been born; if the Hebrew poetry had never been translated; if a revival of the study of Greek literature had never taken place. —Percy Bysshe Shelley, Defence of Poetry (1821) 

And:

–You [literature] lead me first to practice ways of living that are more profound, more sensitive, more intense, and in a curious way more fully generous than I am likely to meet anywhere else in the world. You correct my faults, rebuke my insensitivities. You mold me into patterns of longing and fulfillment that make my ordinary dreams seem petty and absurd. You finally show what life can be…to anyone who is willing to work to earn the title of equal and true friend.—Wayne Booth, The Company We Keep: An Ethics of Fiction (1989) 

Since it was a modern poetry class, I wrapped up the talk with poems by Mary Oliver (“A Poem for the Blue Heron” and “Wild Geese”) and Wendell Berry (“A Vision.”). As we discussed them, I mentioned that the relative popularity of both poets suggests that people still see poetry as much more than an extraneous add-on to our lives. “A Vision,” for instance, has been taken up by climate activists and other environmentalists as they seek to save the world.

So that was my talk. 

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Rethinking the Parable of the Talents

Willem de Poorter, The Parable of the Talents

Sunday

Though Jesus’s Parable of the Talents is often invoked when churches ask congregants for their yearly pledges, thanks to Amy Frykholm (in today’s Journey to Jesus), Diana Butler Bass, and Debie Thomas, I’m now reading it in an entirely different way. The master in the story should not be seen as God, she argues, but rather as a greedy master who wants his underlings to make as much money for him as possible.

In the story, two servants invest the money given them, earning the master’s praise when he demands a percentage, while the third buries it. Bass says that the story should be titled, “The Story of the Courageous Whistleblower,” commending the third servant for telling the truth. In doing so, “he’s cast out. He lost everything,” to which Bass adds, “But Jesus loves outcasts and the poor. It is among them where the Kingdom can be found.”

Here’s enough of the story for you to see her point:

Then the one who had received the one talent also came forward, saying, ‘Master, I knew that you were a harsh man, reaping where you did not sow, and gathering where you did not scatter seed; so I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground. Here you have what is yours.’ But his master replied, ‘You wicked and lazy slave! You knew, did you, that I reap where I did not sow, and gather where I did not scatter? Then you ought to have invested my money with the bankers, and on my return I would have received what was my own with interest. So take the talent from him, and give it to the one with the ten talents. For to all those who have, more will be given, and they will have an abundance; but from those who have nothing, even what they have will be taken away. As for this worthless slave, throw him into the outer darkness, where there will be weeping and gnashing of teeth.’”

As Thomas observes,

Jesus asks nothing of us that he has not done himself.  Just days after telling this parable, he was “cast into the outer darkness” of crucifixion, torment, and death.  Like the third slave, he was deemed “worthless” and expendable by the people who wielded power and influence in his day.  Like the third slave’s costly talent, he was buried in a rock-hewn tomb.  

Apparently, there is a good kind of “worthless” in the economy of God.  May we find the courage to embody it.  

Frykholm, meanwhile, recounts how her minister gave each of the members of his congregation $20 and instructed them to follow the example of the first two servants. After agonizing for weeks, she finally just anonymously returned the money to the church, the equivalent of burying rather than investing it. While the third servant is relatively powerless in the system, Frykholm says that “when he does have an opportunity to call it out, he uses that opportunity to tell the truth and to pay the price.” 

She then applies a Richard Rohr observation to her mental tumult:

If something goes to you with grace and can pass through you and toward others with grace, you can trust it is the choice of God. (The Universal Christ)

The fact that grace was not flowing, Frykholm writes, should have been her first clue. It returned when she opted out of the exercise entirely. She concludes her argument with a George Herbert account of free-flowing grace. Somewhat like Bob Dylan in “Blowin’ in the Wind,” Herbert stacks up nine metaphors to describe the process:

Come, My Way
By George Herbert

Come, my Way, my Truth, my Life:
Such a way as gives us breath;
Such a truth as ends all strife,
Such a life as killeth death.

Come, my Light, my Feast, my Strength:
Such a light as shows a feast,
Such a feast as mends in length,
Such a strength as makes his guest.

Come, my Joy, my Love, my Heart:
Such a joy as none can move,
Such a love as none can part,
Such a heart as joys in love.

If Jesus is the third servant, choosing a heart that loves over money games, then outer darkness does not get the last word.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Why Flannery O’Connor Shook My World

Flannery O’Connor

Friday Memories of Books That Shook My World

As I list books that shook my work, I don’t insist that I remember exactly where I was when first reading them. Nevertheless, when I do, it’s a good indication that the poem or story belongs in this series. I was a 27-year-old graduate student in the building that houses Emory University’s English Department when I sat down to read Flannery O’Connor’s “A Good Man Is Hard to Find.” 

It was a Sunday afternoon on a pleasant autumn day so the building was empty. I was in the graduate students’ lounge preparing to teach the story, which appeared in a fiction anthology graduate students taught. Because I had never encountered O’Connor before, I had no idea what to expect. 

I emerged from the story half an hour later entirely disoriented. I remember stumbling out of the building in a state of shock as I made my way home. I felt that I myself had been in the Georgia countryside witnessing a psycho killer gun down a family.

Shock is O’Connor’s intended effect as the story’s opening gives no indication of what is to come. The early part reads like comic social satire as an unpleasant grandmother and her unpleasant family are preparing to take a weekend excursion into the countryside. A disagreeable narcissist, she trades jibes with the two older children, both thoroughly disagreeable themselves. Meanwhile, her long-suffering son takes the wheel. The mother, who carries a baby on her lap, is pretty much silent throughout the story.

Thanks to the grandmother’s faulty memory, the family gets lost. Then disaster happens when the family cat, which she has smuggled aboard against orders from her son, gets loose and jumps on him, causing the car to run off the road and flip over. His wife suffers a broken shoulder, the injury catching the reader off guard. Like the car, the story has veered into unexpected terrain.

It only gets worse. Three men find them and the grandmother unfortunately blurts out the identity of the leader, whom she has seen on wanted posters. Known as the Misfit, he is a killer who has escaped from jail. While the situation has changed, however, she remains as aggravating as ever, causing her son to swear at her. The Misfit might have killed the family anyway, but being recognized seems to seal the deal.

The father, mother, and children are taken off by the gang members, and we hear the shots as they are murdered. Needless to say, at this point in the story we have reached the point of no return.

O’Connor, however, still has a surprise awaiting us. It appears that only something this drastic can penetrate the grandmother’s narcissism, getting her to care for someone beside herself. Unexpectedly, her concern is for the Misfit:

His voice seemed about to crack and the grandmother’s head cleared for an instant. She saw the man’s face twisted close to her own as if he were going to cry and she murmured, “Why you’re one of my babies. You’re one of my own children!” She reached out and touched him on the shoulder. 

The story is striking in and of itself, but I think other reasons account for why it affected me as deeply as it did. While I’m not the narcissist the grandmother is, like her I have lived a life of privilege, cocooned from the world by my education and middle-class upbringing. Until I graduated from college and married Julia, other people had been largely responsible for my well-being.

Meanwhile, my father’s hoping that his children would restore his innocence after witnessing the horrors of Dachau led me to close my eyes to human depravity. I had read about human evil, of course—the Birmingham church bombing, the Kent State killings, the My Lai massacre—but they were abstract. A short story somehow made evil real for me.

Because of this, the grandmother’s moment of compassion, comparable to Jesus’s forgiveness on the cross, felt all the more extraordinary. Although, like Peter, she betrays Christ—” Maybe He didn’t raise the dead,” she says to the Misfit after failing to soften him by invoking Jesus—in the end she understands Jesus’s love for the first time in her life. 

Although I wouldn’t become a church member for another 15 years (I described myself as a secular humanist), the symbolism hit home. Maybe love was more powerful than death. My sense of disorientation arose over how the story shook up various certainties.

The Misfit is witness to this transcendent moment. The grandmother has penetrated the shield he has erected around his humanity, which is buried so deep he himself doesn’t know it’s there. I think of the final moment in the movie Dead Man Walking, where a man who has committed a horrific murder glimpses “the peace that passeth all understanding” in the moment before the executioner’s lethal injection ends his life. Sister Prejean has been telling him about God’s love throughout his time on death row, but only at the end does he get it. 

The Misfit had thought that he and the grandmother are fellow narcissists and to this point he has been right. Terrified by the world her love opens up for him, however, he leaps back and kills her. Better to eradicate the new possibilities than acknowledge them.

The Misfit sprang back as if a snake had bitten him and shot her three times through the chest. Then he put his gun down on the ground and took off his glasses and began to clean them.

His wise but darkly comic summation shows that the moment has hit home. “She would of been a good woman,” he says, “if it had been somebody there to shoot her every minute of her life.”

And then, because he has glimpsed the light before choosing to reject it, he sums up life from the perspective of one to whom the world appears darker than it ever has before. It comes as he chastises gang member Billy, who is experiencing a sadistic high from the group’s murderous joyride:

“Shut up, Bobby Lee” The Misfit said. “It’s no real pleasure in life.”

I was a long way from embracing Christian faith at this point in my life, but I can see how the story articulated my sense that my rational mind, with its materialistic understanding of the universe, could only take me so far. O’Connor took me into realms I had no language for. Episcopalian ritual and the Book of Common Prayer have gotten me a little closer.

Jesus has proved the good man who was hard to find.

Previous Posts of Books That Shook My World
A Teenager Pinned and Wriggling on the Wall (Nov. 6, 2026)
Tell-Tale Heart Terrified Me as a Teen (Oct. 30, 2026)
Why I Hated Catcher in the Rye (But Not Any More) (Oct. 23, 2026) 
The Iliad Saved My Freshman Year (Oct. 16, 2026) 
At 12 I Fell in Love with Taming of the Shrew (Oct. 9, 2026) 
Alice Captured My Childhood Anxieties (Oct. 2, 2026)
How Tintin Gave Shape to My Sense of Wonder (Sept. 25, 2026)
E. Nesbit’s Formative Moral Influence on My Life (Sept. 18, 2026)
Lord of the Rings: Trudging up Mount Doom with Frodo (Aug. 28, 2026)
The Silver Chair and a Childhood Love (Aug. 21, 2026)
My Childhood Encounter with Wind in the Willows April 14, 2026)

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Eros vs. Death: A Soldier Daydreams

Thursday – Veterans Day

Yesterday (or perhaps today, depending on where you are in the world) was Veterans Day so I share a poem beloved of my father, a translator for the Third Army during World War II. He included Harry Reed’s “Naming of Parts” in his poetry anthology Poems of War Resistance (Grossman, 1969), but I’m only now understanding its significance for him.

Most of the great war poems understandably feature combat. Scott Bates, however, used to observe that books about the army usually fail to capture the soldier’s full experience. I remember him writing to Paul Fussell and Studds Terkel, authors of books about World War II, pointing out they had left out soldier sex. While he didn’t stray himself—we Bateses are fairly Puritanical when it comes to sex—he witnessed much while carrying out military police duties in liberated Paris and occupied Berlin. Terkel wrote back acknowledging that he should indeed have included the subject. 

“Naming of Parts” gets at another aspect of the military that often gets missed, which makes it a good poem for Veterans Day: my father used to mention the mind-numbing boredom. Reed’s poem starts with the voice of a drill instructor and then follows a recruit’s thoughts while the man is nattering on. The Latin inscription is from a Horace love poem in which the Roman poet employs war imagery to describe his sexual exploits: “Recently I lived suitable for warfare, and I soldiered on not without glory.” Alan Michell, to whom the poem is dedicated, was a friend of Reed when the two were engaged in Japanese code-breaking at Bletchley Park:

The Naming of Parts
By Henry Reed

To Alan Michell
                              Vixi duellis nuper idoneus
                            Et militavi non sine gloria

Today we have naming of parts. Yesterday, 
We had daily cleaning. And tomorrow morning, 
We shall have what to do after firing. But today, 
Today we have naming of parts. Japonica 
Glistens like coral in all of the neighboring gardens, 
And today we have naming of parts. 

This is the lower sling swivel. And this 
Is the upper sling swivel, whose use you will see, 
When you are given your slings. And this is the piling swivel, 
Which in your case you have not got. The branches 
Hold in the gardens their silent, eloquent gestures, 
Which in our case we have not got. 

This is the safety-catch, which is always released 
With an easy flick of the thumb. And please do not let me 
See anyone using his finger. You can do it quite easy 
If you have any strength in your thumb. The blossoms 
Are fragile and motionless, never letting anyone see 
Any of them using their finger. 

And this you can see is the bolt. The purpose of this 
Is to open the breech, as you see. We can slide it 
Rapidly backwards and forwards: we call this 
Easing the spring. And rapidly backwards and forwards 
The early bees are assaulting and fumbling the flowers: 
They call it easing the Spring. 

They call it easing the Spring: it is perfectly easy 
If you have any strength in your thumb: like the bolt, 
And the breech, and the cocking-piece, and the point of balance, 
Which in our case we have not got; and the almond-blossom 
Silent in all of the gardens and the bees going backwards and forwards, 
For today we have naming of parts.

The juxtaposition of poetic lyricism with the dull but deadly mechanics of war reminds me of a similar contrast in Wilfred Owen’s “Strange Meeting,” perhaps the greatest of all anti-war poems:

Whatever hope is yours,
Was my life also; I went hunting wild 
After the wildest beauty in the world, 
Which lies not calm in eyes, or braided hair, 
But mocks the steady running of the hour, 
And if it grieves, grieves richlier than here.

Reed’s poem for the most part implies rather than directly comments. Only towards the end, after balancing the two points of view, does he note that humans lack balance. Nature goes on naturing while we obsess over weapons of war.

The poem’s phallic imagery (bolt, breech, cocking piece) led me to wonder whether Reed was homosexual and whether Alan Michell was his lover. A quick check of the internet informed me that he was indeed gay and had a lover at Bletchley, but this lover was not Michell but one Michael Ramsbotham. At any rate, the contrast between fertile nature (“the early bees are assaulting and fumbling the flowers”) and mechanistic warfare brings to mind Stanley Kubrick’s movie Doctor Strangelove: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Love the Bomb.

I’ve written in the past about the film’s depiction of mechanistic sex. It concludes with a masturbatory Captain Kong riding the bomb down to nuclear annihilation, the ultimate orgasm. Strange love indeed. 

The movie is unfortunately only too relevant as our current “Secretary of War” (as Pete Hegseth calls himself) appears to model himself on General Jack D. Ripper. The name is a pun, and Hegseth, charged in the past with sexual assault, is as obsessed with testosterone as Ripper is with “precious bodily fluids.” Pray that the film doesn’t prove predictive, with Trump and Hegseth “dropping the big one” on Iran in an attempt to salvage their manhood. 

But back to Reed’s poem. I think of how my poet father, a lover of nature, may have allowed his mind to wander as drill sergeants bellowed out instructions about sling swivels. Seldom in America have we seen a clearer instance than eros pitted against death. There’s no better way to honor our veterans than by keeping America out of future wars. 

Speaking of sex: When my father returned to Carleton College in January of 1946, he got in trouble with President Larry Gould for publishing a story in the literary magazine about a repressed young soldier who suddenly encounters a Paris brothel, does a 180, and in the ensuing months contracts multiple cases of venereal disease. One sees in the story my father’s fascination with the road he didn’t take, but one wasn’t supposed to talk openly of such matters on college campuses in those days.

In a related story, which my mother used to tell with great relish, another of her soldier boyfriends—as innocent as my father—went to a Paris brothel thinking it was a restaurant. When he asked the prostitute at the door where he should go, he was told (imagine this being delivered with batted eyes and in a sultry voice), “Upstairs.” Every once in a while, out of the blue, my mother would smile mischievously and intone in the thickest French accent she could muster, “Upstairs!”

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Will DJT Give Us a “Name of the Rose” Ending?

Sean Connery in Name of the Rose

Wednesday

While we are properly joyous about last Tuesday’s rejection of Trumpism, we don’t know how much damage the president and fascist enabler Stephen Miller can do over the next two years. The final scene in Umberto Eco’s The Name of the Rose haunts me with one dark possibility.

I’m traveling and so don’t have the novel before me, but (as I recall) disaster strikes after justice has seemingly prevailed. Franciscan monk William of Baskerville (the Sherlock Holmes reference is deliberate) has been called in to solve a murder in a Benedictine abbey with an impressive library. Further murders are committed while he is there, some of them involving blackened lips and fingers. Ultimately we learn that a rediscovered Aristotle manuscript is at the heart of the mayhem.

Before moving on, here’s an observation about the library by Baskerville’s assistant Adso of Melk:

Until then I had thought each book spoke of the things, human or divine, that lie outside books. Now I realized that not infrequently books speak of books: it is as if they spoke among themselves. In the light of this reflection, the library seemed all the more disturbing to me. It was then the place of a long, centuries-old murmuring, an imperceptible dialogue between one parchment and another, a living thing, a receptacle of powers not to be ruled by a human mind, a treasure of secrets emanated by many minds, surviving the death of those who had produced them or had been their conveyors.

Adso comes to realize how vulnerable books are:

A book is a fragile creature, it suffers the wear of time, it fears rodents, the elements and clumsy hands. so the librarian protects the books not only against mankind but also against nature and devotes his life to this war with the forces of oblivion.

Given the dangers of oblivion, the monks find intoxicating the discovery of an Aristotle manuscript discussing the virtues of comedy that no one knew existed. A sequel to The Poetics, the philosopher’s exploration of tragedy. the work is so important that no monk who comes across it can resist opening it and diving in.

The blind monk Jorge, however, believes the book to be an abomination because he regards laughter as a sin. Given the veneration that monastic scholarship accords to Aristotle, he fears that a book celebrating comedy will corrupt all who read it. He therefore coats the edges of the manuscript with arsenic, correctly anticipating that anyone reading it will lick his finger to turn the pages.

Baskerville confronts Jorge with his crime and, very much in the manner of Holmes, explains how he has penetrated the mystery. As I recall, he exhibits some of the same smug self-satisfaction that we see in Arthur Conan Doyle’s great detective. Readers, meanwhile, are glad the crime has been solved. We’re at the point in my political parallel where America rejoices over the country’s rejection of Trumpism. 

Unfortunately, the self-destructive blind monk still has a trick up his sleeve. First, he begins to eat the poisoned pages. Then, when a horrified Adso rushes forward to prevent him, he grabs the lantern (he can sense its heat) and disappears into the stacks. Before long, the entire library is aflame and the great collection is destroyed. Baskerville and his assistant escape the conflagration but are broken men.

Will Trump and Miller do something comparable, setting the world on fire now that they are desperate. Rightwing commentator Tucker Carlson, who has become critical of the president, fears that he will drop a nuclear bomb on Iran. Miller, meanwhile, burns with the fanaticism of the true believer, which means that he may double down on his attacks on immigrants, small fishing vessels, and people he disagrees with. We can expect that Budget and Management Director Russell Vought, a primary architect of the Heritage Foundation’s Project 2025, to be similarly fanatical. Their goal is maximum destruction.

At the end of the novel we are told Adso returns to the ruins of the abbey years later. His goal: to salvage scraps and fragments and begin building a new library. We need our own rebuilding project.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

Richard II Enables Grifting Caterpillars

Richard II

Tuesday

I’m teaching Richard II in my Ljubljana Shakespeare class today and boy does it look different than when I taught it two years ago. Then, of course, Joe Biden was president, so when I looked at the play, the passages about corruption landed differently. They hit home now. 

In the play, Shakespeare addresses an impossible situation: an incompetent monarch is destabilizing a country that relies on a hereditary monarchy for social stability. As bad as Richard II is—I’ll get to his screw-ups in the moment–overthrowing him has consequences that last for generations.

Democracies are superior to monarchies (and autocracies) because the institutions are more important than the ruler: impeaching a leader does not harm the institution because provisions for impeachment are written into the Constitution. That document, affirmed by the original colonies and amended since, is essentially our monarchy. Our own dire consequences occur when the Constitution is assaulted.

I therefore found myself thinking of Trump as a mixture of Richard II and Henry Bolingbroke/ Henry IV. On the one hand, Trump, like Richard, is incompetent, narcissistic, sadistic, and corrupt.  But like Henry, his assaults on the fundamental social contract—the Constitution in Trump’s case, the divine right of kings in Henry’s—threatens to unleash social upheaval.

In the course of the play Richard proves to be

—incompetent: he botches a quarrel between two noblemen;
—corrupt: he confiscates Henry Bolingbroke’s land to pay for his Irish war;
—susceptible to impulsive actions and wild mood swings;
—arrogant and deaf to good advice;
—enabling of corruption in others: : Bushy, Bagot, and Green are characterized as “caterpillars of the commonwealth,” feeding off its green foliage.

As this last image indicates, Shakespeare uses gardening analogies to capture corruption’s effect on England. The image begins with the gardener’s assistant asking why he must keep working with the country in turmoil. His account describes what Trump and his grifters are doing to the nation:

Servant: Why should we in the compass of a pale
Keep law and form and due proportion,
Showing, as in a model, our firm estate,
When our sea-walled garden, the whole land,
Is full of weeds, her fairest flowers choked up,
Her fruit-trees all upturned, her hedges ruin’d,
Her knots disorder’d and her wholesome herbs
Swarming with caterpillars?

The gardener sounds like Democrats predicting corruption investigations. The king that allowed “this disordered spring,” he says, “hath now himself met with the fall of leaf.” As a result, the grifters are no longer protected: 

The weeds which his broad-spreading leaves did shelter,
That seem’d in eating him to hold him up,
Are pluck’d up root and all by Bolingbroke,
I mean the Earl of Wiltshire, Bushy, Green.

Trump has been promising the shelter of leafy-green pardons for all his fellow grifters. We will see.

I feel the gardener’s subsequent lament in my bones. What could America have accomplished if it lopped away this corrupt conman rather than electing him twice to the presidency?

Gardener: O, what pity is it
That he [Richard] had not so trimm’d and dress’d his land
As we this garden! We at time of year
Do wound the bark, the skin of our fruit-trees,
Lest, being over-proud in sap and blood,
With too much riches it confound itself:
Had he done so to great and growing men,
They might have lived to bear and he to taste
Their fruits of duty: superfluous branches
We lop away, that bearing boughs may live:
Had he done so, himself had borne the crown,
Which waste of idle hours hath quite thrown down.

Instead we got a sadist in chief, who takes the same delight in cruelty that Richard does when he visits John of Gaunt on his deathbed. Having exiled Henry, Richard plans to seize his father’s wealth the instant he dies:

Now put it, God, in the physician’s mind
To help him to his grave immediately!
The lining of his coffers shall make coats
To deck our soldiers for these Irish wars.
Come, gentlemen, let’s all go visit him:
Pray God we may make haste, and come too late!

Tyranny expert Tim Snyder talks about those law firms, universities, and others who have “bent the knee” to Trump. Richard is all about people bending knees. Here he is addressing rebellious Henry:

We are amazed; and thus long have we stood
To watch the fearful bending of thy knee,
 Because we thought ourself thy lawful king:
And if we be, how dare thy joints forget
To pay their awful duty to our presence?

As we watch DJT despoil the nation, John of Gaunt’s deathbed lament could be ours:

This royal throne of kings, this scepter’d isle,
This earth of majesty, this seat of Mars,
This other Eden, demi-paradise,
This fortress built by Nature for herself
Against infection and the hand of war,
This happy breed of men, this little world,
This precious stone set in the silver sea,
Which serves it in the office of a wall,
Or as a moat defensive to a house,
Against the envy of less happier lands,
This blessed plot, this earth, this realm, this England,
This nurse, this teeming womb of royal kings,
Fear’d by their breed and famous by their birth,
Renowned for their deeds as far from home,
For Christian service and true chivalry…
This land of such dear souls, this dear dear land,
Dear for her reputation through the world,
Is now leased out…

England may stand strong against foreign enemies, Gaunt goes on to say, but now it is conquering itself: 

That England, that was wont to conquer others,
Hath made a shameful conquest of itself.
Ah, would the scandal vanish with my life, 
How happy then were my ensuing death!

I said that Trump is a combination of Richard and Henry so let’s now switch hats. Richard becomes poetic once he is being deposed, and I imagine America suffering the fate he predicts for England were the Constitution to be overthrown: 

That every stride he makes upon my land
Is dangerous treason: he is come to open
The purple testament of bleeding war;
But ere the crown he looks for live in peace,
Ten thousand bloody crowns of mothers’ sons
Shall ill become the flower of England’s face,
Change the complexion of her maid-pale peace
To scarlet indignation and bedew
Her pastures’ grass with faithful English blood.

Richard talking to the men who have come to arrest him could be Democrats talking to Attorney General Todd Blanche. Once a president can order the Department of Justice to go after his enemies, what’s to keep a Democratic president from sending governmental attorneys after you? For that matter, why wait for a Democratic president? If you fall out of favor with Trump, as Northumberland will with Henry, then you could be the next victim. That’s what you get when you disregard the rule of law:

And he shall think that thou, which know’st the way
To plant unrightful kings, wilt know again,
Being ne’er so little urged, another way
To pluck him headlong from the usurped throne.
The love of wicked men converts to fear;
That fear to hate, and hate turns one or both
To worthy danger and deserved death. 

Richard can predict confidently here because Shakespeare knew historically that Northumberland and his son Hotspur would rebel against Henry in Henry IV, Part I. Put expediency over the law and this is what you get. Our rightwing Supreme Court needs to hear this speech.

To sum up, Trump attempted a Bolingbroke-like coup on January 6, and more recently his caterpillars have been eating away at the commonwealth, with him the hungriest caterpillar of them all. It’s time for Democratic gardeners to start pulling weeds.

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , | Leave a comment

  • Sign up for my weekly newsletter